United StatesNew York StateNew York CityManhattanGreenwich VillageWest Village

Magnolia Bakery

13 people want to go here. 75 people have been here.

People who have been here

47 out of 53 people (88%) think this place is worth visiting.

inthesedreams

wisepig

anydoorway

Pixiechix

marezydotes

chaiextrahot

gopher646

Meredith

twelvepopples

chorusgirl

my768

Mary Hawkins

niftygal

MFM

nosyrosie

Entries

You

Pixiechix
San Francisco

Worth visiting!

A review of this place: Cupcakes from Heaven

The most delicious cupcakes and cheese cake that I would fly across the country for. The lines can be long, but always worth it!


marezydotes
Baltimore

Not worth visiting!

A tip I have about this place

The Cupcake Cafe is way better – this place is just trendy right now. Everyone wants to stand in that line. The cupcakes are tasty, but feel like a brick in your stomache…the ones from the Cupcake Cafe are light and airy, just not in the cool neighborhood.


inthesedreams
21 places

Worth visiting!

The first time I went to this place

... was yesterday!

We didn’t have much of a line, either, which was awesome!

Yummy yummy cupcakes. I had a blue one and a green one. Vanilla cake, those colored frostings. Yummy yummy!


chaiextrahot
New York City

Worth visiting!

ice box cake

ok so there’s always a line out the door, wrapped around the corner. but, it’s one of those iconic new york city spots that you gotta try at least once! i live in nyc and i love heading down to magnolia for TWO very good reasons. their ice box cake and the banana pudding. because they are the best. sure, their cupcakes may not be the best but their ice box cake and banana pudding are. seriously. it’s worth every single calory!!


gopher646
New York City

Not worth visiting!

Untitled

This is a cute shop to walk past and peek into the window, but definitely not worth waiting in line for a cupcake. Everytime I have friends/family in town, they want me to take them to Magnolia. After a few times, I finally said enough, and I let them go off on their own to find it.

The cupcakes are not the best, it’s just a lot of hype. The frosting tastes like someone mixed sugar and Crisco together.

Go if you must, but go to Buttercup bakery to avoid the lines. It’s the exact same recipe (the original owners had a feud. one went off and started Buttercup, using the same recipes).