Carrick
Seattle

Mixed feelings

I went through a period of revering FLW, but given the deplorable state of the American suburbs, and the obvious negative effects on society and the environment that suburbanization brings, I find Wright’s Utopian vision flawed. Nevertheless, I still love to look at and visit his buildings. I’ve been all over Oak Park and other Chicago neighborhoods, been up and down the Guggenheim numerous times, took the tour at Falling Water, and visited a planned community of “Usonian” homes in Upstate New York that never quite flourished. Taliesin would be a great addition to that checklist.


Comments:

Mitch Nussbaum
Madison

See Taliesin, and Madison too

If you’re interested in Frank Lloyd Wright, you should definitely pay a visit to his home town someday.

Taliesin, and related buildings (Hillside Home School, the windmill, etc.) are beautiful, and the setting, in the hills by the Wisconsin River, is romantic and poetic.

If you want to understand Wright, his aesthetic and his ideas, I think it’s useful to see Taliesin. It’s also interesting to visit the family cemetery across the road, next to Unity Chapel. Wright isn’t buried there any more (Mrs. Wright had him exhumed, cremated and moved to Arizona after her death), but his very dramatic grave is still there, and Mamah Borthwick Cheney is not far away.

Madison (where Wright actually grew up) is kind of a museaum of Wright’s architecture, with examples from most stages of his life, including the Unitarian Church, the first Usonian house, and Monona Terrace, which is more or less his design, even though it was not built until the 1990’s.

ovx
Milwaukee

Aren't all utopian visions flawed?

I think Mr. Wright can hardly be blamed for the state of the american suburbs. In fact, Wright was working against that status quo in his Usonian scheme.

That said, I don’t think he was infallible… Wright made mistakes and claimed credit for others successes (while learning from both). Even so, I still feel that his art, architecture, planning projects, and general strife towards human decency show that his heart was, for the most part, in the right place.


Add a comment

Carrick has gotten 1 cheer on this entry.